INTERNAL TENSIONS AT BRIGHTON: Players Reportedly Challenge Kaoru Mitoma’s Leadership Role
Tensions are reportedly rising within the Brighton & Hove Albion camp as several senior players have begun to question Kaoru Mitoma’s leadership, following his appointment as club captain ahead of the 2025/26 season. The Japanese international, known for his quiet demeanour and electrifying performances on the pitch, was chosen by the club’s management in a surprise move that appears to have caused a rift behind the scenes.
According to reports from local and national media, the dressing room has become increasingly divided, with certain players expressing dissatisfaction with what they perceive as a “premature” and “externally driven” decision to hand Mitoma the captain’s armband.
Mitoma’s Rise and Leadership Appointment
Kaoru Mitoma has been one of Brighton’s standout performers since joining the club from Kawasaki Frontale in 2021. His flair, consistency, and tireless work ethic quickly won over supporters, making him a fan favourite. After several seasons of excelling on the wing, his influence grew both on and off the pitch.
When former captain Lewis Dunk announced his retirement from football earlier this summer, Brighton’s management made the bold decision to hand the captaincy to Mitoma — a move praised externally as progressive, but apparently met with skepticism within the squad.
Manager Francesco Farioli defended the decision at the time:
“Kaoru leads by example. He is respected across the squad and admired for his dedication and professionalism. We believe leadership comes in different forms, and Kaoru has all the attributes we want to inspire this next generation.”
Dressing Room Unease
However, sources close to the club have indicated that several key figures within the squad, including a group of long-serving senior players, were “surprised and disappointed” by the appointment. Some reportedly felt that the armband should have gone to a player with a stronger vocal presence in the dressing room or one who has spent more time with the club.
Tensions reportedly came to a head during a recent training session, where two players — whose names are being withheld — challenged Mitoma’s authority over tactical decisions. While the altercation did not turn physical, it marked a rare moment of visible friction within what has traditionally been a well-unified Brighton squad.
One source was quoted as saying:
“There’s no issue with Kaoru the player — he’s one of the best. But being captain means leading in more than just performance. Some players feel blindsided by the decision and believe it wasn’t discussed properly within the team.”
Support From Club Management
Despite the unrest, Brighton’s board and coaching staff are standing firmly behind Mitoma, urging players to embrace a new era of leadership.
Club Chairman Tony Bloom issued a statement late Tuesday evening:
“Leadership transitions are always challenging, especially after the legacy of someone like Lewis Dunk. But we have full confidence in Kaoru. His professionalism, humility, and drive make him the ideal figure to lead this club forward.”
The club also emphasized that no disciplinary action would be taken regarding the internal dispute but warned that continued dissent would not be tolerated.
Mixed Fan Reactions
Supporters are also divided. While many fans admire Mitoma for his consistency and sportsmanship, others are questioning whether he has the personality to galvanize the team through adversity.
One Brighton supporter posted on social media:
“Love Mitoma as a player, but captain? Not sure he’s the kind to rally the lads when it’s tough. Feels like a PR decision.”
Others were more optimistic:
“Mitoma’s earned this. Leads with his feet. Maybe not loud, but neither was Dunk. Let’s give him a chance.”
What’s Next for Brighton?
The internal unrest comes at a crucial time as Brighton prepare for the upcoming Premier League season. The club is also balancing Europa League commitments, making strong leadership and unity essential.
Mitoma himself has yet to respond publicly to the reported unrest, though those close to him say he is focused on his responsibilities and is committed to earning the full respect of the dressing room.
Brighton are set to travel to Spain for their pre-season training camp next week — a period that could prove critical in resolving underlying tensions and reestablishing team harmony.
Final Thoughts
While Kaoru Mitoma remains one of Brighton’s brightest stars, his elevation to club captain has clearly not been universally welcomed within the squad. Whether this internal challenge proves to be a brief storm or a more lingering leadership crisis may depend on how Mitoma responds — and whether his critics within the squad can put personal feelings aside for the greater good.
What is certain is that Brighton, a club long admired for its unity and cohesion, now faces a leadership crossroads. The path they choose could shape the tone of their upcoming campaign.
As pressure mounts, Mitoma’s toughest challenge may not come from opponents — but from within.
