Newcastle United and Nottingham Forest in Talks Over Shared Deal for Harvey Barnes
June 3, 2025 — In a surprising twist to the summer transfer window, Newcastle United and Nottingham Forest are reportedly in advanced negotiations over a unique partnership deal involving winger Harvey Barnes. The agreement, still being formalized, could see Barnes split time between both clubs next season — a move aimed at maximizing playing time while managing financial constraints amid Premier League Profit and Sustainability Rules (PSR).
The proposed arrangement is believed to be the first of its kind in modern English top-flight football, where two Premier League clubs collaborate to manage a player’s development and impact. Sources close to both clubs indicate that Barnes could be loaned to Nottingham Forest for the 2025–26 campaign, with Newcastle retaining long-term control over the player’s contract and future.
A Deal Born of Strategy
Newcastle United signed Harvey Barnes from Leicester City in July 2023 for a reported £39 million, but his first season was hampered by injuries and intense competition on the flanks. While Barnes showed flashes of his explosive pace and goal-scoring prowess, consistent minutes were hard to come by in a side stacked with attacking talent like Anthony Gordon, Miguel Almirón, and Jacob Murphy.
Manager Eddie Howe remains a fan of Barnes but recognizes that the 27-year-old needs regular minutes to rediscover his best form. Rather than offload him permanently, Newcastle are seeking a creative solution — one that ensures Barnes remains in the Premier League spotlight while opening up room in the squad and helping the club remain compliant with spending regulations.
Forest, on the other hand, see Barnes as the kind of proven top-flight performer who could instantly boost their attacking options. The club narrowly avoided relegation last season and are eager to reinforce their wide positions after the departure of Callum Hudson-Odoi and ongoing uncertainty around Morgan Gibbs-White’s future.
The Structure of the Deal
While details are still emerging, the structure of the partnership is expected to resemble an “enhanced loan agreement,” whereby Newcastle covers a portion of Barnes’ wages and maintains a buy-back clause or right of recall. Forest would take over a significant share of the financial responsibility and commit to offering Barnes a starting role, enabling him to stay match-fit and regain sharpness.
The key twist lies in the agreement between the clubs to collaborate on player performance targets, development milestones, and future valuation — ensuring that both parties benefit. Such a partnership, while unconventional, could set a precedent for how Premier League clubs navigate the increasingly complex financial landscape.
“Both clubs are looking at this as a win-win,” said a source close to the negotiations. “Harvey gets the minutes he needs, Forest get a high-quality player, and Newcastle stay within financial fair play limits while protecting their asset.”
Barnes Ready for Revival
Harvey Barnes, once a standout performer at Leicester, remains a player of immense talent. Known for his direct running, sharp dribbling, and ability to score from range, he was tipped to become a regular in the England setup before injuries and inconsistency slowed his momentum.
Speaking earlier this year, Barnes expressed his frustration at the lack of consistent opportunities but reiterated his desire to fight for his place: “I know what I can bring to a team. I’ve worked hard to stay fit and sharp, and I’m ready to make an impact — wherever that may be.”
A move to Forest could offer him just that platform. Under manager Nuno Espírito Santo, Forest have shown a willingness to adapt tactically and give creative players freedom in the final third. Barnes’ style — vertical, aggressive, and clinical — suits a counter-attacking setup, making him an ideal addition to Forest’s front line.
A Glimpse Into the Future of Transfers?
This potential Newcastle–Forest deal also raises broader questions about how Premier League clubs might navigate increasingly tight financial regulations. As the league clamps down on excessive spending and encourages sustainable squad-building, creative player-sharing arrangements could become more common.
Football finance expert Kieran Maguire noted: “If structured properly, such deals allow clubs to be more agile. It’s not dissimilar to how partnerships work in other sports like basketball or baseball, where player development is more centralized. In football, it’s new territory — but potentially game-changing.”
For Forest, who have historically struggled to attract top-tier talent without committing to large transfer fees, this could become a model for securing high-impact players on manageable terms. For Newcastle, it’s a way to navigate depth management while retaining control over player value.
Fan Reactions Mixed But Curious
Fan reaction to the proposed deal has been mixed, with Newcastle supporters divided over the decision to loan a player many believe still has much to offer. Some see it as smart business; others fear it signals Barnes’ eventual departure.
“I like Barnes — he’s got end product,” said one Newcastle fan on X. “But if we’re serious about Europe, we need every tool in the box.”
Meanwhile, Forest fans are buzzing with excitement at the prospect. “Barnes is exactly what we need — pace, goals, and Premier League experience,” one supporter wrote. “If we pull this off, it could be our best signing of the summer.”
What’s Next?
With discussions advancing quickly, an announcement could come as early as next week. The deal will need to be ratified by the Premier League, with both clubs eager to finalize terms before pre-season begins in early July.
Whether this is a one-off or the beginning of a trend, one thing is clear: Newcastle and Forest are breaking the mold in how clubs collaborate — and Harvey Barnes may just be the first beneficiary of a more cooperative footballing future.
